Discuss NICEIC REPORT - feedback on remedial works costs in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

duckie

-
Reaction score
10
NICEIC REPORT - feedback on remedial works costs

Hi all - I had an test done in advance of selling my 3 bed semi. The test report has four C2, nine C3 and two F1s.

I wanted to get your expert and unbiased feedback on these observations to help make sure I do the right remedial works - as well as getting an indication for prices. (I am in London South West and been quoted £950k for remedial works - see image)

I have attached photos of the report + some of the issues pointed out to give a better idea. Appreciate any feedback and tips - thanks a lot.
 

Attachments

  • EICR faults.jpg
    491.6 KB · Views: 135
  • IMG_20200923_110536.jpg
    481 KB · Views: 123
  • IMG_20210204_145943.jpg
    492.4 KB · Views: 108
  • IMG_20210204_195508.jpg
    501.5 KB · Views: 96
  • IMG_20210204_195524.jpg
    526.7 KB · Views: 94
  • IMG_20210204_195532.jpg
    416.3 KB · Views: 95
  • IMG_20210316_180533.jpg
    668.9 KB · Views: 97
  • IMG_20210316_180625.jpg
    678.1 KB · Views: 93
  • IMG_20210316_180644.jpg
    730.5 KB · Views: 101
  • remedial works quote.jpg
    297.1 KB · Views: 115
I hope that is £950 and not £950k !!!

From a quick look it seems a fair report as the C2 mentioned are reasonable (the lack of RCD on sockets, etc, can be C3, but if for circuits in a bathroom then C2). The report does not seem to mention the Wylex RCBO shoe-horned in to the CU, that is really a C2 itself due to the "modifications" involved!

Some background reading for you can be had here if you want detailed guidance:

I don't do this sort of work professionally so I can't comment on the price, but for a CU change and other remedial work in London it also seems fair. Anything below about £500 would be unlikely for a professional job (i.e. someone with the overheads of proper insurance, competent scheme membership fees, test equipment calibration, actually paying taxes, etc).

You might get other quotes/comments from folk on here but I don't see anything outrageous here.
 
Sorry, stand corrected, the "modification" is listed as point 5 and classed as C3 (but BPG#4 has C2):

Mixed branded switchgear components within a consumer unit or distribution board where:
  • there are no signs of thermal damage to component or associated connections
  • the enclosure/assembly hasn’t been modified to allow installation of the component
  • the component is securely fitted and all connections are adequate
  • correct manual operation of the component
  • direction of use of toggles/switches is the same as existing devices
Note: If any of the above criteria is not met, this would warrant a code C2 classification to be recorded.
 
I think it's a bit unprofessional quoting for a new 'fuseboard' , very old terminology and it should at least specify whether it'll be a dual RCD or RCBO unit , also whether Surge Protection is or isn't included. But the price looks fair to me if they're quoting for an RCBO board with Surge Protection.
 
£945 + VAT!
Living out here in the sticks you would be lucky to be able to charge £650 + VAT, perils of London rates I suppose.

Could explain why some people down here with holiday homes pay us to drive up for the day to do works at thier london homes, thought it was because we do a good job and they liked us, oh well.
 
I think it's a bit unprofessional quoting for a new 'fuseboard' , very old terminology and it should at least specify whether it'll be a dual RCD or RCBO unit , also whether Surge Protection is or isn't included. But the price looks fair to me if they're quoting for an RCBO board with Surge Protection.
Not sure who 'patrice' is too - french inspector perhaps?

From the photo it almost looks like the inner shell is not actually broken anyway, which would not make it a C2 - though the cost of a pattress is not going to make much difference either way...
 
£950 for a new consumer unit with new main bonding is a decent price. You are not obligated to change it just to sell the house. But its a nice thing to do so you can point out to prospective buyers you had it done.
I've had several people call and ask for EICR because they are selling, and were surprised when I pointed out it wasn't actually a legal requirement - presumably some estate agents are pushing this as a 'service' at a nice mark up...
 
That towel rail connection is the result of poor workmanship and whoever doctored that 40A rcbo into that consumer unit have destroyed it beyond repair and now the whole unit needs replacing.
Wylex stuff often has troubles fitting their own older boards, but that's almost impressive levels of bodgery
 
I've had several people call and ask for EICR because they are selling, and were surprised when I pointed out it wasn't actually a legal requirement - presumably some estate agents are pushing this as a 'service' at a nice mark up...
We are being asked more and more frequently for this - I think the mortgage lenders have cottened on to the fact that their 'surveyers' don't have a clue what they are talking about. (I'm buying another property to let at the moment, the surveyor said it is of a sandstone and brick construction - the whole road is made from limestone and brick - can't even tell the difference between 2 of the most common rock types)
 
The price sounds a little on the high side for Kent, but not massively so and may be quite normal for the area involved - assuming it was an SPD RCBO board then would not be an outrageous price I'd think - but it will be a balance as to whether it will be recouped in the sale (may depend on whether a buyer is looking to move directly in, or will be gutting and rewiring...)

There are probably cheaper ways to get a 'satisfactory' EICR if that is what you want. Though adding RCD protection for the bathroom circuits (if that is what the report is highlighting), might require a new consumer unit in any case as there are no officially compatible parts available for that consumer unit I believe.
 
We are being asked more and more frequently for this - I think the mortgage lenders have cottened on to the fact that their 'surveyers' don't have a clue what they are talking about. (I'm buying another property to let at the moment, the surveyor said it is of a sandstone and brick construction - the whole road is made from limestone and brick - can't even tell the difference between 2 of the most common rock types)
It makes a lot of sense as a buyer to have one done (or factor in the cost of a new consumer unit), but I doubt it is a deciding factor in many purchases, just a haggle point.

Of course if they'd been included in the Home Information Pack as planned, then maybe things would be different by now. It may be something that insurance companies or mortgage companies make more or less a 'requirement' sooner rather than later I suspect.

Most surveys I've seen just say "the electrical installation should be checked by a qualified person" to cover themselves...
 
Noticed the quote states "refit", rather than supply and fit, which seemed odd.
Seen this done loads of times with these decorative metal flat switches, they often don’t have a proper flex out point, so the sparks just squashed the flex under that plate or notches some of the plaster out to fish the flex behind the plate.
bear rough but seen this a hundred times or more
 
Seen this done loads of times with these decorative metal flat switches, they often don’t have a proper flex out point, so the sparks just squashed the flex under that plate or notches some of the plaster out to fish the flex behind the plate.
bear rough but seen this a hundred times or more
If it's the BG ones (maybe others), they actually have the flex point in the plastic behind too - just no hole in the metal. I assume that's because they use the same back bit on various models rather than they expect you to cut a hole in the front!
 
There was no need for the Report to quote this as separate issues. The cord is not suitably restrained from its local isolator leaving conductors exposed.
 
I've had several people call and ask for EICR because they are selling, and were surprised when I pointed out it wasn't actually a legal requirement - presumably some estate agents are pushing this as a 'service' at a nice mark up...
It was quite common many years ago for solicitors doing the conveyancing to suggest the buyer got a PIR / EICR
In the mid 80's when I was buying my first house the solicitor was pushing the benefits of the PIR, she was not sure what to say when I pointed out that I knew all the potential issues with the installation and without lifting the floorboards they would not be found by paying for a PIR
 
It does but you cant re-terminate to something that is not fit for purpose in that there is no flex outlet point and doubt a means for restraining flex within......... It needs replacing.

There's no question that it needs to be replaced, but the reason I raised the issue was because the quotation stated 're-terminate' for that outlet, but 'supply and fit' for the damaged surface box.

Perhaps it was a poorly worded quotation, but it does beg the question...
 
I wouldn't even have a switched/fused spur in a bathroom, regardless of zones and compliance. I much prefer the SFCU outside with a flex outlet plate adjacent to the towel rail.
 
No idea where they came from or who made them, and they've been there for years, but on one of my shelves I have a couple of what I can only describe as 1G 10mm thick plastic 'spacers', with a cable outlet hole at the bottom, that are intended to sandwich between a plate and its mounting box.
 
I hope that is £950 and not £950k !!!
CORRECT, It is indeeds £950 and not £950k ..... which would be 2x the costs of the entire property !!! I might as well give the property keys to them for free !! I am actually in TW18 postcode so not proper London but still London pricing in most cases!

That towel rail connection is the result of poor workmanship and whoever doctored that 40A rcbo into that consumer unit have destroyed it beyond repair and now the whole unit needs replacing.
You hit the nail on the head. I had mentioned this in my initial intro posts when I joined the forum but long story short - hired a builder/contractor do all the jobs in the house on basis he would be getting proper professionals for each specific jobs - electricians for the wiring work, bathroom fitter for bathroom work and so on. It turned out he had a "Jack of all" foreman and assistants who was doing most of the work... so I fired them but not until most of the work was done. I then was left with getting other specialists to fix their "work" .... now with selling of the property I have to do part of the paperwork which asks for electrical work done in past 2 years - and if don then supply the certificates. I did not know that the certificates would be critical and required which the builder never provided when firing him - besides I was done dealing with him by then. We live and learn is the approach I have taken and hence trawling each specific trade forums and seeking opinions and unbiased feedback from the experts!!

As part of the sale the solicitor wanted me to give an "ECIR Test" stating quality of works hence the need for getting everything fixed to pass any test.

I think it's a bit unprofessional quoting for a new 'fuseboard' , very old terminology and it should at least specify whether it'll be a dual RCD or RCBO unit , also whether Surge Protection is or isn't included. But the price looks fair to me if they're quoting for an RCBO board with Surge Protection.
This is helpful and I will ask whoever is quoting for this job to very specific about the unit. (y)
Completely an inappropriate accessory for the job! ......... No suitable flex outlet on a flatplate design.
See above ... it was a bodge job and to make life easier I will be asking for this bathroom wiring to be removed and made "dead". The radiator is dual fuel and works with the central heating so remoing the electrics option wont hurt.
I've had several people call and ask for EICR because they are selling, and were surprised when I pointed out it wasn't actually a legal requirement - presumably some estate agents are pushing this as a 'service' at a nice mark up...

We are being asked more and more frequently for this - I think the mortgage lenders have cottened on to the fact that their 'surveyers' don't have a clue what they are talking about. (I'm buying another property to let at the moment, the surveyor said it is of a sandstone and brick construction - the whole road is made from limestone and brick - can't even tell the difference between 2 of the most common rock types)

It makes a lot of sense as a buyer to have one done (or factor in the cost of a new consumer unit), but I doubt it is a deciding factor in many purchases, just a haggle point.

Of course if they'd been included in the Home Information Pack as planned, then maybe things would be different by now. It may be something that insurance companies or mortgage companies make more or less a 'requirement' sooner rather than later I suspect.

Most surveys I've seen just say "the electrical installation should be checked by a qualified person" to cover themselves...
Its a standard clause now in the buyers declaration form for the solicitors. If there are no electric works certificates/installation certificates then EICR tests are asked to make sure the wiring are fine and safe.

If it's the BG ones (maybe others), they actually have the flex point in the plastic behind too - just no hole in the metal. I assume that's because they use the same back bit on various models rather than they expect you to cut a hole in the front!
They are the BG "screwless" ones which I chose for looks but quite difficult to fit if the walls are not even. My learning was that ones with screws would have been more apt but yes, the builders team did not do as good a job as they could have.
It does but you cant re-terminate to something that is not fit for purpose in that there is no flex outlet point and doubt a means for restraining flex within......... It needs replacing.

There's no question that it needs to be replaced, but the reason I raised the issue was because the quotation stated 're-terminate' for that outlet, but 'supply and fit' for the damaged surface box.

Perhaps it was a poorly worded quotation, but it does beg the question...
True and I will be asking this to be made "dead".

I have to says this is one of the most friendliest and HELPFUL trades forums I have experienced so far. You has reassured to my actual worry about my quote and that I might be getting "ripped off" with unnecessary works by the tester and his electrician mate.

Armed with all the feedback I aim to now get a few quotes - not sure if the forum rules allow members to pitch for work as I will be quite happy to get someone on here to give me a quote and do the job.

cheers and thanks a lot.
 

Reply to NICEIC REPORT - feedback on remedial works costs in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

Hi I recently had an electrical test done on my flat prior to a sale. The flat won't have had much work done in many many years so i was...
Replies
28
Views
3K
hi i had an EICR report done for a property i let. It had a number of C1 and C2 observations. I got a different electrician to come in and...
Replies
21
Views
3K
Hi everyone Ive just had an electrical condition report conducted on a mixed-use property, and I am extremely surprised that after the last report...
Replies
11
Views
2K
Hi all, have just ordered my first EICR ever for a studio to 1-bed conversion flat in London. It cost a little less than £80 and the electrician...
Replies
51
Views
8K
Hi, hopefully, you can help me by giving some guidance over the EICR which has failed for my rented property. It was carried out by an electrician...
Replies
16
Views
4K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock