Discuss Advice on safety of new Consumer Unit Install in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net
Even worse than I expected.
I know, its gone past shocking and got to upsetting now.
So should I just go through check-a-trade complaint system, or should I give him the opportunity to put it right? Or just save up for someone else to put it right?
it's not clear exactly which bits he extended in that mess - any new cabling he added would be in the new colours surely? (perhaps I'm assuming too much!).To be honest I couldn’t wait any longer myself so I’ve just nipped round to the house and pulled the floorboards (by hand) as he didn’t re fit them properly and to be honest I didn’t think it could get any worse
He had to extend the cables as they would not reach so everything your about to see is what he has done. They may be the original JBs but he has re used them and, Well. Here you go. Have a look
One of the JBs I couldn’t open because it’s so tort to the ceiling/floor plasterboard that there is no play to twist it enough to open the screw let alone move it. And this is how I found it so nothing secured all floating with bare circuits (al be it a dead old shower 6mm (doesn't look like 10mm, maybe 6mm so probably better i didnt have him re-connect it as it was running an 8.5kw shower). I asked him not to reconnect as we’re removing it for mixer shower off boiler)
I’m pretty upset to be honest. I know it was only £250 but I thought it would be done to at least a basic standard. I could have done that better if I was allowed, I’m not and he is and he has certificates telling people he is allowed to install that and why oh why oh why. Any way. Any Thoughts on the JBs?? (I say sarcastically), He couldn't even put any sleeving on the bare cpc's.
I did safely isolate before opening the JBs
View attachment 98981View attachment 98982View attachment 98983View attachment 98984View attachment 98985View attachment 98986View attachment 98987View attachment 98988View attachment 98989View attachment 98990View attachment 98991View attachment 98992View attachment 98993View attachment 98994View attachment 98995
Was he a limbo dancer? He seems to keep managing to slide under the bar, no matter how much I've lowered it after reading each post!Even worse than I expected.
Well done for having all that information together - it will certainly help. Do you have any invoice or proof of payment?I have a paper trail and a lot of evidence now compiled.
a) The before and after photos
b) The incorrect certificate with his name, address and signature on
c) The original contact request through check-a-trade website
d) All the text messages between us regarding appointment times, etc etc and the conversation regarding the wrong certificate.
so he will be hard pressed to say it was not him that installed it.
I have text him for his email address, so I can put it all in writing with images with regards to the problems found and see what he wants to do. Problem is it was only £250, I can imagine its going to cost 3 times that to put it right and safe, those JB's are not safe.
I can believe that, and it's upsetting to see work like this.I know, its gone past shocking and got to upsetting now.
I can believe that, and it's upsetting to see work like this.
A passing thought - Is there any way you could have an incorrect name and address? I'm just wondering if he isn't actually the person you looked up. Don't get me wrong, there are some real cowboys in CPS schemes but the price charged is so low and I struggle to see how anyone can work to this standard, make ends meet, and have any interest in remaining in a competent person scheme. By the time insurance, scheme membership, publications, calibration is factored in I can't see how he's making any money if he's in a scheme.
As above, you can complain to Napit. In theory they stand behind the quality of work and warranty it for a long time afterwards. They may uphold the complaint, but to my knowledge they can only insist the same member rectifies things - I've never known or heard of any other outcome.
Have you paid the bill yet? I'm guessing so.
I think there are two routes forwards. Either go to Napit as @Dartlec said above. Or....
You may consider writing a letter of complaint saying that there is a consensus from some other electricians that the work is not up to standard in several ways, and you would like a partial refund (total bill less Screwfix price for that CU). If he would like 3rd party arbitration then you are happy to approach Napit and Check-a-trade to obtain impartial advice and confirmation that the work is up to standard.
You are concerned about the following aspects:
-Failure to confirm that supply was in a safe condition before work started
-Unauthorised conversion of earthing system to TN
-Cables inadequately contained
-Access to live parts
-Cables inadequately supported
-Consumer unit missing parts and inadequately supported.
-Incorrect certification
-Notifiable works being carried out without notification occurring.
(I could go on)
This doesn't prevent you going to Napit if you get no response.
Great post, thank you, and thank you to every other member who has chipped in with advice...
Unfortunately I paid cash, only thing I have is a paper trail of him quoting £250 and on the same day me withdrawing £250 from cash machine (Nottraceable I know) but hey ho.
It seemed like he did it as a side job, he came at 16:30 pm and finished about 19:15 so it seemed looking back now that he did his days graft and this was a side job on the way home to earn extra spending money/beer money/....... if you get what I mean.
He had a young lad with him (Apprentice maybe?) poor lad if he is an apprentice learning from him.
The address and name on the certificate he gave does match up with whats on check-a-trade contact details and he is trading as a LTD company. <<His Name>> Ltd. so for example Joe Bloggs Ltd.
That, his phone number, LTD company reg details and check-a-trade and Napit all match, I didn't go as far as asking for his ID / driving licence to check it was him when he arrived but I'm sure it was the person named on the certs and sites. But i can imagine in the past people have created whole untraceable personas/ids to do such things..
As upset as I am with the ordeal, I suppose I will have to chalk it down to experience and try be even more thorough in future when selecting tradesmen/women.
Shocking work. Just an FYI, 6mm is fine for an 8.5kw shower as long as the run isn't massive.To be honest I couldn’t wait any longer myself so I’ve just nipped round to the house and pulled the floorboards (by hand) as he didn’t re fit them properly and to be honest I didn’t think it could get any worse
He had to extend the cables as they would not reach so everything your about to see is what he has done. They may be the original JBs but he has re used them and, Well. Here you go. Have a look
One of the JBs I couldn’t open because it’s so tort to the ceiling/floor plasterboard that there is no play to twist it enough to open the screw let alone move it. And this is how I found it so nothing secured all floating with bare circuits (al be it a dead old shower 6mm (doesn't look like 10mm, maybe 6mm so probably better i didnt have him re-connect it as it was running an 8.5kw shower). I asked him not to reconnect as we’re removing it for mixer shower off boiler)
I’m pretty upset to be honest. I know it was only £250 but I thought it would be done to at least a basic standard. I could have done that better if I was allowed, I’m not and he is and he has certificates telling people he is allowed to install that and why oh why oh why. Any way. Any Thoughts on the JBs?? (I say sarcastically), He couldn't even put any sleeving on the bare cpc's.
I did safely isolate before opening the JBs
View attachment 98981View attachment 98982View attachment 98983View attachment 98984View attachment 98985View attachment 98986View attachment 98987View attachment 98988View attachment 98989View attachment 98990View attachment 98991View attachment 98992View attachment 98993View attachment 98994View attachment 98995
wow, this is shocking. It might be worth noting that the board is in the same configuration as is sold on Screwfix. If you have any photos of the original boards it might be useful to check if the circuits are on the correct size devices. Odd that they used a tails gland
Given that cables were extended, the board could be dressed in any configuration.
Why would you consider it odd that they brought the tails in through a gland?
I think he means it's surprisingly professional compared to the rest of the work.
Yup exactly that. The glands are £7 on a £45 board.I think he means it's surprisingly professional compared to the rest of the work.
Yup exactly that. The glands are £7 on a £45 board.
Any ideas on what was done with the cables that were going to the contactor?
He most definitely should not have taken it, it belonged to EON. Were the off peak circuits no longer required.
It's actually a £70 board, with Type A RCDs - he really went the extra mileYup exactly that. The glands are £7 on a £45 board.
That work isn't notifiable no. Is that the circuit that is no longer needed, or is it planned to be reused for something in the future?Is replacing that broken JB under the bedroom floor for say a new wiska box and wago connectors notifiable? Am I allowed to do it?
That work isn't notifiable no. Is that the circuit that is no longer needed, or is it planned to be reused for something in the future?
If it's 6mm, then Wago do 6mm lever connectors, but they are not suitable for use in their Wago boxes as a designated Maintenance Free box (for whatever reason) - Only the push fit Wago ones (773-173) are.
Unless the appliance is pulling over 47a, 6mm is fine.Te
There are 2 x 6mm circuits. one is bare and not terminated under the floorboards which was the old shower which I told him to leave out. I wont be re-suing it and will be ripping it out from the bathroom eventually. ( un-terminated 6mm shown in one of the images)
The other 6mm is the cooker circuit. Its roughly a 6 meter run from dp cooker switch up the wall to under landing floorboards through bedroom and down to that junction box just over the ceiling above the cu.
I thought 10mm was better for cooker? Now I know its 6mm I take it I should stay away from installing an induction hob when fitting the kitchen!
Te
There are 2 x 6mm circuits. one is bare and not terminated under the floorboards which was the old shower which I told him to leave out. I wont be re-suing it and will be ripping it out from the bathroom eventually. ( un-terminated 6mm shown in one of the images)
The other 6mm is the cooker circuit. Its roughly a 6 meter run from dp cooker switch up the wall to under landing floorboards through bedroom and down to that junction box just over the ceiling above the cu.
I thought 10mm was better for cooker? Now I know its 6mm I take it I should stay away from installing an induction hob when fitting the kitchen!
I wonder what sort of van he had..........was there a horse pulling it?I’m not condoning anything this charlatan has done, but a handwritten test certificate is just as acceptable as a computer generated one… it was the way things were always done not that long ago…. And it looks like he’s attempted to fill things in… some cowboys don’t even bother.
EIC versus EICR… yeh ok… a consumer unit change should be an EIC, but an EICR shows all the same information and is (wrongfully) demanded by letting agents rather than an EIC.
To think the guy never even had a bit of green/yellow sleeving in the van….
A Reliant Supervan III, obviously! (very niche geek accuracy there...)I wonder what sort of van he had..........was there a horse pulling it?
Probably nicked from work. I wonder if he's not qualified...just labouring with the day job. No way the to$$er's registered.It's actually a £70 board, with Type A RCDs - he really went the extra mile
The gland confused me too - shows that some competence went into it, which makes the rest all the more baffling.
There is handwritten and there is scrawl and the cert is definitely a piece of inaccurate scrawlI’m not condoning anything this charlatan has done, but a handwritten test certificate is just as acceptable as a computer generated one… it was the way things were always done not that long ago…. And it looks like he’s attempted to fill things in… some cowboys don’t even bother.
All down to education or more likely the lack ofEIC versus EICR… yeh ok… a consumer unit change should be an EIC, but an EICR shows all the same information and is (wrongfully) demanded by letting agents rather than an EIC.
He only charged £250 the sleeving was probably going to be an extraTo think the guy never even had a bit of green/yellow sleeving in the van….
The way the NICEIC have gone in the last few years it amazes me they are still in business, it seems there are plenty of schemes and business lead companies not stepping up to the plate with proper vetting of those they allow on their registers and the electrical industry is embarassing itself by continuing to allow these outfits to operateRepeating what others have said… being listed on check a trade, my builder, even the NAPIT or NICEIC websites does not guarantee competence… however these companies may claim.
Finding a reliable tradesman is very different to finding one with the skills and competencies to complete the job to a standard that meets the regs and looks like it has a professional finishThe best place to find a reliable tradesman is, as it’s always been, word of mouth.
Even the ones on here, I can’t trust them as far as I can throw ‘em….
All your points, except the one regarding earth sleeving , have been regular topics on this forum for the last ten years, or more. Nothing is going to change, the infestation of our trade is too deep, as you know.There is handwritten and there is scrawl and the cert is definitely a piece of inaccurate scrawl
All down to education or more likely the lack of
Ha Ha are you having a laugh...looking at the pics he wont even know what they areDid the electrician offer you Surge or Arc fault protection, and as you are going to be letting the property you are going to need fire detectors.
Lol what's up with getting the unit from Screwfix? They're cheap.My eyes are still bleeding from looking at those pics....Absolutely disgusting install, Tell the so called sparky that Screwfix which guaranteed is where he got the Consumer Unit from also sell rubbish bins and he should buy one then PUT ALL HIS TOOLS INTO IT
It is just a shame they don't ask for evidence of competence if buying parts, like a CU, that are only ever for notifiable work.Lol what's up with getting the unit from Screwfix? They're cheap.
Others have already answered this as "it is fine" but the more detailed reason is for domestic cookers (not commercial kitchen!) the approved diversity calculation for the cable & supply protection rating is 10A plus 30% of remainder, or more detailed:I thought 10mm was better for cooker? Now I know its 6mm I take it I should stay away from installing an induction hob when fitting the kitchen!
Do electrical wholesalers in general ask if joe public comes in and pays cash?It is just a shame they don't ask for evidence of competence if buying parts, like a CU, that are only ever for notifiable work.
No, but I guess Joe Public is not as likely to go in and ask as they are when they see them advertised on the walls of Toolstation and Screwfix.Do electrical wholesalers in general ask if joe public comes in and pays cash?
It’s not just screwfix.
Which is worrying, given that wholesalers may have good knowledge of the products they sell (or have had manufacturer 'training' on), but don't in my experience have much knowledge about regulations or what is needed to do a compliant install.A mate of mine is the manager of a wholesalers and they get joe public and some supposedly qualified sparks asking them what they need to do various electrical jobs and talking to other wholesalers it is becoming more common to be asked what they reccommend for jobs
They aren't awful - I think they suffer some by selling most of their stock through the sheds.I am giving BG the benefit of the doubt not a bad panel it does have a level built in !
I forgot to point out they offer no advice on what to use for a particular job but may offer alternatives if the customer asks for a particular product and they have a number of different items in stockWhich is worrying, given that wholesalers may have good knowledge of the products they sell (or have had manufacturer 'training' on), but don't in my experience have much knowledge about regulations or what is needed to do a compliant install.
Some of them can be a good source of knowledge on products for sure, certainly compared to Screwfix staff!I forgot to point out they offer no advice on what to use for a particular job but may offer alternatives if the customer asks for a particular product and they have a number of different items in stock
Very true. I have found the guys at my local Holland House to be helpful, they will get any stuff I specifically ask for, but often have suggestions of alternatives that they stock and have little problems with which occasionally turn out to be better than my original idea.Some of them can be a good source of knowledge on products for sure, certainly compared to Screwfix staff!
Probably know best which lights/accessories don't come back often too, as it's in their interest.
But then there is always the risk that they are on a higher percentage on certain makes.
DANGER DANGER DANGERJust to add to your question, it may help it may not. I am one of the end terrace of a terrace of 7. We are all on a looped supply, 1 loop comes up my side wall splits to mine then feeds 2 other properties so 3 of the 7 from the incoming loop on my wall, then the remaining 4 in the terrace are looped together on a separate incoming loop on the end of the wall of the other end terrace the other side.
Its a rubber incoming cable with 2 cores. The earthing arrangement has always been like this.
I have also attached a photo of the setup before he came in and installed the new CU
View attachment 98921
On another note regards the loop, have a look at these pictures and see how dangerous this looks to you
View attachment 98922View attachment 98923View attachment 98924View attachment 98925
Update.
I did ring the DNO, Northern Powergrid, I explained on the phone about the cables being bare, they asked me to email pictures (the exact ones I posted on here) within 45 minutes someone came out to look at them, within 2 hours of that, they (DNO) were digging up the garden and replacing it, So it has been replaced.
DANGER DANGER DANGER
Phone 105 NOW and state you have bare damaged supply cables.
Reply to Advice on safety of new Consumer Unit Install in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net
We get it, advertisements are annoying!
Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.